The Government is considering fundamental changes to the way people qualify for permanent settlement in the UK. The proposals, known as “Earned Settlement”, would replace existing fixed routes to settlement with a system in which the length of time someone must wait could depend on factors including their earnings, occupation, use of public funds and immigration history.

Southwark Law Centre strongly opposes many of the proposals. We are particularly concerned about people who have already built their lives in the UK being moved onto much longer routes to settlement, and about the impact on refugees, children, carers, disabled people and people in low-paid work.

We submitted a detailed response to the Government consultation earlier this year. Our position is straightforward: a settlement system should provide security and support integration. It should not make people’s lives more precarious or make permanent status substantially easier to achieve if you are wealthy.

What is being proposed?

Under the Government’s proposals, the standard qualifying period for settlement would increase to 10 years, with that period then capable of being shortened or extended depending on a person’s circumstances.

Some people in lower-paid or lower-skilled work could face a 15-year route, while refugees could face a 20-year route to settlement. At the same time, higher earnings could significantly reduce the period someone has to wait.

The Immigration Law Practitioners’ Association (ILPA) has described the proposals as without precedent in the UK’s own history or comparable countries. Its research found that Canada, Australia, New Zealand and most EU countries provide settlement within two to five years, and that it is aware of no comparable country with a 20-year route for refugees.

We do not believe someone’s contribution to society can reasonably be measured by how much they earn. Cleaners, carers, shop workers and many other people in relatively low-paid jobs make an essential contribution to our communities. So do parents and unpaid carers.

As we said in our consultation response, the pandemic demonstrated the value of many of these roles. A settlement system should recognise contribution in all its forms rather than creating a system in which those with the highest incomes can obtain security most quickly.

Keep the promise: protect existing routes to settlement

One of our greatest concerns is what happens to people who are already living in the UK on a route to settlement.

People have come to this country and been told by the Home Office that, provided they continue to meet the relevant requirements, they are on a particular pathway to permanent status.

They have built careers and families, saved for immigration applications and made long-term decisions on that basis. Some will already have spent years progressing along that route.

We believe that promise should be honoured.

People who are already on a route to settlement should be allowed to complete that route under the existing rules.

Changing the rules part-way through could mean someone discovering, after years of living and working here, that permanent status is suddenly another five, ten or even more years away. As we explained in our consultation response, people have made significant financial and life decisions in reliance on the route the Home Office told them they were on.

The people most affected will often be those with the least

We are also concerned that the proposed system risks penalising people for circumstances beyond their control.

People with disabilities or long-term health conditions may not be able to work full time. Parents and unpaid carers may have lower incomes because of their caring responsibilities. People experiencing domestic abuse, homelessness or exploitation may need to rely on the safety net provided by benefits and public services.

Yet under the proposals, accessing public funds could result in someone having to wait substantially longer for settlement.

Our consultation response warned that this could have a particularly damaging unintended consequence: people may become frightened to ask for help when they need it, increasing their vulnerability to destitution, abuse and exploitation.

Children are another particular concern. Prolonged temporary immigration status affects the whole family, creating financial insecurity and uncertainty about their future in the country in which children may have spent much or all of their lives.

Refugees need security, not decades of uncertainty

The proposed treatment of refugees is particularly troubling.

People who have been recognised as refugees have been accepted by the UK as needing international protection because they cannot safely return to their country of origin.

Under Earned Settlement, refugees could instead face a default 20-year route to permanent settlement. ILPA notes that this would be four times the five-year period that had applied since the 1990s.

Keeping someone in temporary immigration status for decades does not promote integration. It prolongs insecurity and makes it harder for people to put down roots, rebuild their lives and participate fully in their communities.

What does this mean for Southwark?

Immigration policy is decided nationally, but its consequences are felt locally.

At Southwark Law Centre, we see what happens when people’s immigration status becomes precarious. Longer and more complicated routes to settlement can mean greater financial hardship, difficulties maintaining employment and increased risks of homelessness and exploitation. They can also place additional pressure on local authorities and voluntary-sector services.

Many of the people affected by Earned Settlement are already part of our community. They work here, raise families here, have children in local schools, volunteer and participate in community life.

Creating a system in which people can live in the UK for 10, 15 or 20 years without the security of permanent status risks achieving the opposite of the integration the Government says it wants.

Southwark Council has recently strengthened its commitment to protecting migrant communities, including through work with neighbouring boroughs towards an anti-raids sanctuary corridor. We welcome that commitment and want to see the same principles reflected in the response to Earned Settlement.

The Government can still change course

The consultation has closed, but the final Earned Settlement scheme has not yet been decided.

That makes now an important time to speak up.

Southwark Law Centre is calling for:

  • people already on a route to settlement to have their existing route honoured;
  • refugees not to be subjected to decades of temporary status;
  • proper safeguards for children, carers, disabled people, survivors of abuse and others who would be disproportionately affected; and
  • the equality, economic and wider consequences of the reforms to be properly assessed before changes are implemented.

But opposition to these proposals cannot come only from immigration lawyers and advice organisations.

What can you do?

Write to your MP. Ask them to raise Earned Settlement with the Home Secretary and press the Government to honour existing routes to settlement. Ask them to raise concerns about the proposed 20-year route for refugees and about a system that could penalise people because they are low-paid, disabled, have caring responsibilities or have needed to access the welfare safety net.

Contact your local councillors. Ask them what their council is doing to protect local residents who could be affected and to make representations to Government. If you live in Southwark, ask your councillors to support the Council taking a clear public position on Earned Settlement, consistent with its wider commitments to migrant communities.

Talk about Earned Settlement. Many people who could be affected do not yet know about the proposals. Share information with your friends and colleagues and through community groups, workplaces, trade unions, faith groups and other organisations you are involved with.

Ask organisations you belong to to speak up. Community organisations, charities, employers, trade unions, faith organisations and professional bodies can write to the Home Secretary and MPs, make public statements and explain how prolonged insecure immigration status would affect their members, workers and communities. ILPA is similarly encouraging organisations and communities to raise these concerns with MPs and add their voices publicly to the debate.

The message we want decision-makers to hear is clear:

Keep the promise to people who have already built their lives here. Do not change their route to settlement part-way through. Do not make refugees wait 20 years for security. And do not create a settlement system in which wealth determines how quickly someone can belong.

Earned Settlement is not yet a finished policy. This is the time to speak up.

We’ve created a simple template letter for you to use to write to your MP and local councillors.